Metanet Forums

A topic to gather a full list of all the maps that made it to 100 rates or more. And sorry, the cut-off is at 100, any below is excluded or else this list would be way too long to handle. To those that say comments are more important in 'Newma', I agree, but I'm collecting a full list, not suggesting we do a massive collab, or anything to make a new map reach 100. So bite me, I don't care anymore about those comments (if you decide after I post this edit to tell me again), because I've heard it so many times already, and believe it myself as well.

In conclusion, I present you with a gathering of maps:

1. Afternoon Dragon Step04 by Dragon_Moon (nart: 1172)
2. The improbability drive by formica (dda: 805)
3. The Crazy Miner by formica (race: 495)
4. My Hero by wedgie123 (nart: 457)
5. Manotechnology by nevermore (dda: 393)
6. Tattletale by nevermore (dda: 356)
7. Dungeons of Dooms: Final Showdown by mithril_silver (dda: 350)
8. On route 666 by Clifty (dda: 339)
9. Doors V by Clifty (dda: 298)
10. Rocket-ed. by formica (dda: 270)
11. Michelle Five'fer by maximo (dda: 267)
12. Pinball by arachnid (action: 268)
13. The Glasses Are Off by espada777777 (nart: 266)
14. Dragon Portraet 01 by Dragon_Moon (nart: 257)
15. Silverdragon by Dragon_Moon (nart: 234)
16. Mother Thwumping Impossible by blue_tetris (action: 229)
17. Psychotic Mined Games by Sendy (minejumper: 220)
18. The Right Angle by Clifty (dda: 217)
19. Valves by Lucidium (puzzle: 208)
20. Lovely Lovely by PALEMOON (scandal: 222)
21. Firecracker by Clifty (dda: 189)
22. Rocket Rage by killerman (dda: 170)
23. The Chasers War III : Identity Crisis by romaniac (dda:166)
24. Throwback by maximo (dda: 165)
25. Anyway, the N-way by MARIJNENANDRIES (race: 166)
26. Dungeons of Doom: The chase by mithril_silver (dda: 164)
27. Gauge Invariance by Lucidium (dda: 163)
28. The Spirit of Fire by Dragon_Moon (nart: 159)
29. Thunder King by im_bad_at_n (nart: 167)
30. Thriller by Sendy (dda: 156)
31. A Dark Secret by mrgy05 (nart: 155)
32. Fossil by Zorn (action: 154)
33. Impossibility within as Impossible Triangle by romaniac (nart: 153)
34. My Little Pony by wedgie123 (nart: 153)
35. I think he did something wrong, did he? by Dragon_Moon (nart: 146)
36. Speak by nevermore (action: 147)
37. Hedge by Zorn (squeeze: 141)
38. Mount Doom by maximo (minejumper: 139)
39. Face Off II: Grudge Match by bluenin and Clifty (dda: 141)
40. Shrine by Zorn (action: 132)
41. Acid Rain by Clifty (dda: 134)
42. The Chaser Wars II : Double Agent by romaniac (dda: 132)
43. Super Mario 3 by mrgy05 (nart: 134)
44. Chase. by incluye (dda: 129)
45. Dragon Moon Knew It by ]{no3 (nart: 129)
46. Shot Shot by formica (race: 122)
47. Desperado by JeffKillian (action: 120)
48. City Skyline {Mk. III} by AMomentLikeThis (nart: 119)
49. Feraligatr by LordOfPeanuts (nart: 118)
50. Claustrophobic by MARIJNENANDRIES (race: 118)
51. Jaguar by RavenMac (nart: 118)
52. Afternoondragon 02 --- Relax above the skyes by Dragon_Moon (nart: 117)
53. Really pretty quite sorta fast by formica (race: 114)
54. Face Off by Clifty and bluenin (dda: 112)
55. The Firing Squad by incluye (dda: 111)
56. driven by insanity by killerman (dda:111)
57. Psychotic Mind Games II - Slope Psychosis by Sendy (mine jumper: 110)
58. It's My Nightmare and I'll Die if I Want To by Sendy (dda: 108)
59. Six feet under by Clifty (dda: 106)
60. The Chaser's War by Clifty (dda: 106)
61. 3D Yin-Yang by Dragon_Moon (nart: 106)
62. <(-^.^-)> Yo-Yo <(-^.^-)> by LordOfPeanuts (nart: 103)
63. Link by ]{no3 (nart: 101)
64. Compartment by Lucidium (action: 101)
65. Take the bridge, men! by nevershine (action: 100)
66. My Slow Descent into by formica (dda: 100)

[/spoiler]
Sorted by author, by first number of maps in above, then number of total rates in above:

1. Clifty (9 listed, 1641 rates in above)
2. Dragon_Moon (7 listed, 2190 rates in above)
3. formica (6 listed, 1906 rates in above)
4. Sendy (4 listed, 594 rates in above)
5. nevermore (3 listed, 896 rates in above)
6. maximo (3 listed, 571 rates in above)
7. Lucidium (3 listed, 472 rates in above)
8. romaniac(3 listed, 451 rates in above)
9. Zorn (3 listed, 427 rates in above)
10. wedgie123 (2 listed, 610 in above)
11. mithril_silver (2 listed, 514 rates in above)
12. MARIJNENANDRIES (2 listed, 284 rates in above)
13. mrgy05 (2 listed, 289 rates in above)
14. killerman (2 listed, 281 rates in above)
15. bluenin (2 listed, 253 rates in above)
16. incluye (2 listed, 240 rates in above)
17. ]{no3 (2 listed, 230 rates in above)
18. LordOfPeanuts (2 listed, 221 rates in above)
19. arachnid (1 listed, 268 rates in above)
20. espada777777 (1 listed, 266 rates in above)
21. blue_tetris (1 listed, 229 rates in above)
22. PALEMOON (1 listed, 222 rates in above)
23. im_bad_at_n (1 listed, 167 rates in above)
24. AMomentLikeThis (1 listed, 119 rates in above)
25. jeffkillian (1 listed, 120 rates in above)
26. RavenMac (1 listed, 115 rates in above)
27. nevershine (1 listed, 100 rates in above)

[/spoiler]

If there are any errors, please tell me.

Also, this is a list of maps with a great number of ratings, and does not entirely represent all of the best mapmakers on NUMA. Making it to a 100 nowadays is difficult, and mostly unachievable, meaning the actual best won't make it on this list. If your one of these I'm sorry, and I hope you understand.

im_bad_at_n wrote:Generally, my recent success

I stopped reading right here.

Flight wrote:

im_bad_at_n wrote:Generally, my recent success

I stopped reading right here.

Exactly.

QFE to both of the above. Also, there used to be a way to sort all maps on NUMA by the number of votes they've gotten, but that bit of hacking was lost in the transition to NewMA. Either way, nobody who's anybody cares about ratings. If that's why you're making maps, you need to readjust your priorities.

im_bad_at_n wrote:(you know...Thunder King?!?)

No, I don't, sorry. Please inform me in slavering statistical detail.

I have 3 maps that are over 90, but none have surpassed the 100 mark.

Sendy
http://www.nmaps.net/7366

Jeffkillian
http://www.nmaps.net/7575

I can't think of any others. A lot of stepself maps came close.

This would thread would actually be interesting if you put in the links to the maps and the map type (like playable, dda or nart) after it.
I think these kind of stats are quite interesting but they are in no way a measure of quality. Especially since you yourself admitted it is mainly only nartists and dda makers who can make it excluding the majority of mappers who make actual playable maps the main type so calling your list the best of the best sounds ignorant and arrogant.

Please also include the links thanks.

The most I've got is 16 (that was when NUMA was a cooler place) but I know that my maps are well liked. I don't need hundreds of rates to get this. N-arts do get more attention, but I haven't got time on my hands.

I map for comments.

Thanks for all the lists of maps and advice.
Please be aware that if I do not get to it quickly, it does not mean I will not do it, and it definitely does not mean I will forget about it.

Its a lot of work, but I will do it all, I have the motivation. =P

Well, if this is a thread about your most rated map, mine's a dda. And it's the only proper dda I've ever made. In fact, I'm surprised that this got above 10 rates, let alone 25.

I'm surprised y'all forgot about Pheidippides' birthday map already.

Maps seldom make it over 100 rates since newma's initiation. When top-rated was still in existence it was common for maps to have high ratings.

Manus Australis wrote:I'm surprised y'all forgot about Pheidippides' birthday map already.

I was kinda glad it slipped under the radar, actually. But I appreciate that you remembered, pawz. That was an... /interesting/ birthday.

More maps with over 100 ratings for you

http://www.nmaps.net/118369
http://www.nmaps.net/99610
http://www.nmaps.net/175721
http://www.nmaps.net/42676

http://www.nmaps.net/19429

How did you forgot that map? That was the first thing came to my mind when I read the topic title.

With Newma, 100 ratings seems to be an unrealistic goal, at least not unless it is featured, and already very well rated when released. Or by Espada.

I personally have two well rated maps, that is, over 30 ratings, and I am absolutely stoked to have achieved this, especially as one is a playable action. The point I'm trying to make is, don't see maps at 100 rates from the Oldma age, and think that that is the standard for high quality maps. Maps of the same quality are made now, and the bar hasn't been lowered...the community have just taken off their spring-shoes.

I have 4 maps with more than 100 votes, I believe. Good luck finding them.
Also I'm sure Dragon_Moon has at least 10 maps with more than 100 votes.

Ratings mean tiddly-squat these days.

Actually, when I add an author to the list, I check through all his maps for maps with ratings over 100. I think the only person I didnt check all his maps is espada777777 because he has a ton of maps... i've checked through all his recent n-arts to the point where he made action maps though. =P

progress through the lists is very slow though =P

I've got a couple:
151
453

http://www.nmaps.net/52246 has 118
Can't think of any more right now, but I'm pretty sure I have 2 more at least.

This is an unrealistic goal these days. Nonetheless, here are nevermore's greatest hits:

http://www.nmaps.net/17887
http://www.nmaps.net/7471
http://www.nmaps.net/7678

and mithril_silver:
http://www.nmaps.net/17008
http://www.nmaps.net/12084

and Zorn:
http://www.nmaps.net/9155
http://www.nmaps.net/9050
http://www.nmaps.net/8439

and romaniac:
http://www.nmaps.net/96185
http://www.nmaps.net/80833

and bluenin:
http://www.nmaps.net/167518

and how could we ever forget:
http://www.nmaps.net/1

oh and blue_tetris:
http://www.nmaps.net/5080

and maximo:
http://www.nmaps.net/12117
http://www.nmaps.net/660
http://www.nmaps.net/4348

and MARIJNENANDRIES:
http://www.nmaps.net/47750
http://www.nmaps.net/25673

and don't think I'm even started.

Thanks scythe. Updated list, still more to come.

Amlt, im sorry i didnt get all of yours, I cant really search nmaps.net for your rated maps =P it keeps erroring up.

And I know rates are rather impossible nowadays, but this is a list of all that made it, not a topic to try and get another one or whatever... =P

thanks everyone that helped out ^^

Please remove my map from this list. Thanks.