The Signature Tournament; Finals Judging Now!

http://nmaps.net/user/greenblack · Postby **blackbelmoral** » 2009.02.09 (15:02)

i have just submitted my results to him so judging will be finished shortly.

Postby **origami_alligator** » 2009.02.09 (17:54)

Just out of curiosity, how are we being judged? How are our sigs being scored? How do the requirements factor into our score?

All of these things are important and I realized nobody knows.

http://nmaps.net/user/kablamo_boom · Postby **Kablamo** » 2009.02.10 (04:25)

well judging is basicly out of these catergories,

Looks-
Relativeness to theme-
followed the technique-
Well placed images/words-
etc.

anyways its time to annouce the results!!!

these contestants are moving on to the next round!

U.Z
Manus Australis -very close i must say
esay
Daikenkai
Techno
Izzy

thanks for entering! now in this round please PM me the sigs :)

http://nmaps.net/user/esay · Postby **esay** » 2009.02.10 (04:29)

Yay - Beginners luck!
Can you please post all the images plus a few comments so we can have a look?

http://nmaps.net/user/T3chno · Postby **T3chno** » 2009.02.10 (05:30)

Can we at least see what we scored?

http://nmaps.net/user/kablamo_boom · Postby **Kablamo** » 2009.02.10 (05:40)

Sig looks/astecics ?/7
smudging: ?/3
type/relevance of objects relating to theme: ?/6
total: ?/16

uz:
Sig looks/astecics 6.5
smudging: 3/3
type/relevance of objects relating to theme: 4.5/6
total: 14/16

riobe:
Sig looks/astecics 5.5/7
smudging: 1/3
type/relevance of objects relating to theme: 6/6
total: 12.5/16

Nicnac14:
Sig looks/astecics 6/7
smudging: 2/3
type/relevance of objects relating to theme: 6/6
total: 14/16

pawz:
Sig looks/astecics6/7
smudging: 3/3
type/relevance of objects relating to theme: 6/6
total: 15/16

esay:
Sig looks/astecics 5.5/7
smudging: 2/3
type/relevance of objects relating to theme: 6/6
total: 13.5/16

be_inspired:
Sig looks/astecics 6/7
smudging: 3/3
type/relevance of objects relating to theme: 2/6
total: 11/16

wumbla:
Sig looks/astecics 0/6
smudging: 0/3
type/relevance of objects relating to theme: 0/3
total: 0/16

daikenai:
Sig looks/astecics 6/7
smudging: 3/3
type/relevance of objects relating to theme: 5/6
total: 14/16

Incluye
Sig looks/astecics 5/7
smudging: 3/3
type/relevance of objects relating to theme: 5/6
total: 13/16

Techno
Sig looks/astecics 6/7
smudging: 3/3
type/relevance of objects relating to theme: 6/6
Total 15/16

octopod squad:
Sig looks/astecics 5/7
smudging: 3/3
type/relevance of objects relating to theme: 2/3
total: 10/16

izzy:
Sig looks/astecics 6/7
smudging: 3/3
type/relevance of objects relating to theme: 6/6
total: 15/16

http://nmaps.net/user/kablamo_boom · Postby **Kablamo** » 2009.02.10 (07:04)

thanks for not going all losery be_nspired

btw have u unretired?

http://nmaps.net/user/esay · Postby **esay** » 2009.02.10 (07:07)

Haha king esay?
I dont think im quite royalty yet... lol
anyways that sig is kewl as and ill add it to my collection :)
thanks ;D

http://nmaps.net/user/Izzy · Postby **Izzy** » 2009.02.10 (20:17)

Heck yeah, I tied with T3.

I say new judges.

Edit: Astecics? :P

http://nmaps.net/user/Riobe · Postby **Riobe** » 2009.02.10 (20:32)

Ahaha, I'm quite surprised that I got as high a score as I did. My sig looked horrible on the black background.

EDIT: Also, good luck in the second round UZ!

Postby **大見解** » 2009.02.10 (23:09)

CRAP. I SUK AT VEHICLES >_>

And I'm surprised how high marks I got.

EDIT::
hey kablammo? can you post all the sigs so we can see them?

http://nmaps.net/user/Izzy · Postby **Izzy** » 2009.02.11 (02:19)

Submitted mine.

/me prepares to get destroyed by T3.

Oh yeah, can you post the sigs, or at least the ones that were PMed to you?

Postby **origami_alligator** » 2009.02.11 (02:30)

use of theme : x/12
use of technique : x/8
overall look : x/5

I think that makes the competition fair and keeps the theme and the technique as the main focus rather than the end result, which I always find makes things a little more fun if you don't have to worry about losing points because your sig doesn't look amazing.

But it's up to you.

http://nmaps.net/user/greenblack · Postby **blackbelmoral** » 2009.02.11 (02:50)

BE_nSPIRED wrote:im not gonna go all sore losery, cos im not like that but really the judging format is not great, my mark was,.. well yeh...

any way no hard feelings, heres my entry for esay

and for you esay, i vote change your name to king esay =D

heh, the way me and him judged by catergory was a little different, but it still works.

http://nmaps.net/user/kablamo_boom · Postby **Kablamo** » 2009.02.11 (05:08)

Manus Australis wrote:use of theme : x/12
use of technique : x/8
overall look : x/5

I think that makes the competition fair and keeps the theme and the technique as the main focus rather than the end result, which I always find makes things a little more fun if you don't have to worry about losing points because your sig doesn't look amazing.

But it's up to you.

ah thank u those are much better categories and me and blackbel will now take what u have said.

Postby **大見解** » 2009.02.12 (00:12)

can you post all the sigs from round one please?

http://nmaps.net/user/kablamo_boom · Postby **Kablamo** » 2009.02.12 (03:39)

Daikenkai wrote:can you post all the sigs from round one please?

Yes I Can

Universe Zero vs Riobe
NicNac 14 vs Manus Austarlis
esay vs BE_nspired
wumbla vs Daikenkai
Incluye vs Techno
Octopod Squad vs Izzy

http://nmaps.net/user/Naczz · Postby **NicNac14** » 2009.02.12 (13:59)

argh! I lost by 1 point. anyway.. well done pawz!

Postby **大見解** » 2009.02.14 (17:55)

you know, the round can end early if all the submissions are in...

http://nmaps.net/user/greenblack · Postby **blackbelmoral** » 2009.02.14 (18:02)

plz pm me themaps sigs kablamo_boom

http://nmaps.net/user/kablamo_boom · Postby **Kablamo** » 2009.02.14 (19:14)

Daikenkai wrote:you know, the round can end early if all the submissions are in...

Yes i know. but paws and t3chno are yet to send theres in

http://nmaps.net/user/T3chno · Postby **T3chno** » 2009.02.17 (04:47)

About to submit mine. I haven't had much time this week at all.

http://nmaps.net/user/kablamo_boom · Postby **Kablamo** » 2009.02.17 (05:44)

Round 2 is OVER!!!!

thanks everyone, since everyone subbed this time. Once Blackbelmoral goes online ill post the results
BTW all the sigs look awesome, and the next round is a 3 way, the top person makes one for the middle, middle for bottom, and bottom for top incase u were wondering

http://nmaps.net/user/kablamo_boom · Postby **Kablamo** » 2009.02.18 (05:45)

I gotta say it is REALLY hard judging.

The results will be delivered shortly, but in the mean time I might as well post each peoples sigs.

Universe Zero v.s Manus Australis

esay v.s Daikenkai

Techno v.s Izzy

http://nmaps.net/user/UniverseZero · Postby **Universezero** » 2009.02.18 (07:11)

esay's doesn't work.

Metanet Forums

The Signature Tournament; Finals Judging Now!

Who is online